As COVID-19 continues to affect our community, we want to keep you updated. Please click here for more details.

Angelica, NY 14709 21 E Main Street

Pending
21 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 121 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 221 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 321 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 421 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 521 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 621 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 721 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 821 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 921 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1021 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1121 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1221 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1321 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1421 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1521 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1621 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1721 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1821 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 1921 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2021 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2121 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2221 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2321 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2421 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2521 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2621 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2721 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2821 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 2921 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 3021 E Main Street Angelica, NY - Image 31
Presented By: Girard Kelly with Landquest Inc.;
  • MLS# S1618250
  • 06/26/2025
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • SQFT • 40,716

Home Details

This commercial building is located on 4.8 acres in the Village of Angelica NY, Allegany County. Nestled in the heart of the historic Town of Angelica, this commercial property offers a rare opportunity for investors and developers alike. Formerly serving as both an elementary school and high school, this expansive one-story building spans over 40,000 square feet and sits on a generous 4.8 acre lot. The community is highly supportive of redevelopment welcoming a wide array of possibilities for this space. Whether you're envisioning a mixed-use center, office complex, senior assisted living facility, community center, or more, the potential is truly limitless. The building features a large gymnasium with auditorium, a spacious commercial-grade kitchen, and a generous dining area perfect for events or communal use. With a central main office area and three separate wings formerly used as classrooms, the layout is ideal for adaptive reuse. Outside, the property boasts ample parking and is within walking distance to Main Street, Park Circle, the post office, and the Angelica Library offering excellent visibility and convenience. Access to Interstate I-86 is just minutes away making this a prime location for regional connectivity. The Town of Angelica is known as The Town Where History Lives! Angelica has rich historical charm and vibrant community life hosting popular events like car shows, fairs, and seasonal gatherings. An existing survey is available providing a solid starting point for your development vision. Don't miss this unique opportunity to become part of a community that embraces its past while looking toward a dynamic future.
Presented By: Girard Kelly with Landquest Inc.;

Interior Features for 21 E Main Street

Bathrooms

Main Level Bathrooms0
Total Baths

Other Interior Features

BasementPartial
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NNo
Heating Y/NNo
Total Fireplaces
Total Stories1

General for 21 E Main Street

CityAngelica
CountyAllegany
DirectionsI-86, exit 31 to Peacock Hill to East Main St.
Elementary School DistrictGenesee Valley
HeatingOther, SeeRemarks, None
High School DistrictGenesee Valley
Lease Considered Y/NNo
LevelsOne
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaAngelica-Village-023201
Middle/Junior School DistrictGenesee Valley
Number Of Units Total
PossessionCloseOfEscrow
Possible UseOther
Property ConditionResale
Property Sub Type AdditionalCommercial
Property SubtypeCommercial
Property TypeCommercialSale
RoofMembrane, Rubber
School DistrictGenesee Valley
SewerSepticTank
Standard StatusPending
StatusPending
Stories Count1
Tax Annual Amount9974.0
Tax Assessed Value231300
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount0.0
TownshipAngelica-Village
UtilitiesWaterConnected
Virtual TourClick here
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1955
Year Built DetailsExisting
Zoningcomm
Zoning DescriptionCommercial

Exterior for 21 E Main Street

Building Area Total40716.0
InclusionsLand and Building
Lot Dimensions115X627
Lot FeaturesIrregularLot
Lot Size Acres4.89
Lot Size Area4.89
Number of Buildings1
Total Parking100.0
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Paul Buttenhoff

Director of Investor Sales and Acquisitions
Price $349,900
MLS#S1618250
List Date 06/26/2025
Property Type Pending
Phone 646.377.1087
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 21 E Main Street